Top Five Tips In Negotiating a Structured Payout of Divorce Assets

As a Texas divorce lawyer, I've seen many clients struggle with how to divide their assets fairly while ensuring their financial future remains secure.   One of the biggest challenges to coming up with a fair resolution is the liquidity of assets.  When there is an asset that cannot be easily reduced to cash, through sale such as a closely held business or certain real estate, it can be hard to divide the asset in a divorce.  If there are insufficient funds to "buy out" the other party, then a structured settlement with payments over time may be the best solution. In those instances, parties need to be careful to consider the terms of such a structured payout. 

Here are my top five tips to help you navigate this challenging aspect of divorce negotiations.

1. Understand the Value of All Assets
Before you can negotiate a fair payout, it's crucial to understand the true value of all community assets. This includes real estate, investments, retirement accounts, and personal property. Hire a professional appraiser if necessary to ensure accurate valuations.

Example: Suppose you're dividing a marital home valued at $500,000 and investment accounts worth $200,000. An appraisal might reveal that the home needs $50,000 in repairs, effectively reducing its market value. Similarly, an investment account's value might fluctuate based on market conditions, so ensure you have up-to-date valuations before negotiations.

2. Consider the Tax Implications
Different assets have different tax implications, which can significantly impact the overall value of the settlement. It's essential to factor in these considerations to avoid unpleasant surprises down the road.

Example: If one spouse is keeping the family home and the other is receiving a retirement account of equal value, remember that the retirement account may be subject to taxes and penalties upon withdrawal. This means the actual value received could be significantly less than the nominal value. Consulting with a tax professional can help you understand these implications and negotiate accordingly.

3. Include Interest in Long-Term Payouts
When agreeing to long-term payouts, it’s vital to include interest to keep up with the cost of living. Inflation can erode the value of money over time, and without interest, the deal can lose its value.

Example: If you're awarded a structured payout of $200,000 over ten years, ensure that interest is included to account for inflation. At a 3% annual interest rate, the payments will not only cover the principal amount but also compensate for the increase in the cost of living, ensuring you receive fair value over time.

4. Set Clear Terms and Conditions
Clarity is key when it comes to structured payouts. Set clear terms and conditions to avoid disputes and ensure smooth execution. This includes the payment schedule, method of payment, and consequences of late or missed payments.

Example: In your settlement agreement, specify that $2,000 will be paid monthly via direct deposit by the 5th of each month. Include a clause that outlines a penalty for late payments, such as an additional 5% of the monthly amount. This clarity helps both parties understand their obligations and reduces the likelihood of conflict.

5. Plan for Contingencies
Life is unpredictable, and circumstances can change. It's important to plan for contingencies in your structured payout agreement. This could include what happens in case of job loss, disability, or other significant life events.

Example: If the paying spouse loses their job, the agreement might stipulate a temporary reduction in payments, with the unpaid amount added to future payments once they secure new employment. Alternatively, you could include a provision for the payout to be backed by a life insurance policy, ensuring payments continue in case of the payer's untimely death.

Putting It All Together
Let's consider a hypothetical scenario to illustrate these tips in action.

Jane and John are getting divorced after 20 years of marriage. They have accumulated several community assets, including a home worth $400,000, retirement accounts totaling $300,000, and various personal property valued at $100,000.

1. Understanding the Value of All Assets: They hire an appraiser who discovers the home needs $30,000 in repairs. After adjustments, the home's value is set at $370,000. They also update the valuations of their retirement accounts and personal property.
2. Considering the Tax Implications: Jane decides to keep the retirement accounts, but after consulting with a tax professional, they realize the after-tax value is closer to $250,000 due to potential taxes and penalties.
3. Including Interest in Long-Term Payouts: John agrees to a structured payout to Jane of $200,000 over 10 years, with an annual interest rate of 3%. This ensures that the payments keep pace with inflation.
4. Setting Clear Terms and Conditions: They agree on a monthly payment of $1,931.21, to be deposited directly into Jane's bank account by the 5th of each month. A late payment penalty of 5% of the monthly amount is included.
5. Planning for Contingencies: They include a clause that allows for payment adjustments if John loses his job, with unpaid amounts added to future payments. Additionally, John takes out a life insurance policy naming Jane as the beneficiary to cover the remaining payout in case of his death.

Generally, the goal of a divorce is to have your former spouse out of your life.  Avoiding any long term financial entanglements that could complicate your future life is usually the best option.  But sometimes the marital estate cannot be fairly divided without one spouse making payments to the other over a period of time and a payout plan must be developed.   Negotiating a structured payout of community assets in a divorce requires careful planning and attention to detail. By understanding the value of all assets, considering tax implications, including interest in long-term payouts, setting clear terms and conditions, and planning for contingencies, you can ensure a fair and secure financial future for both parties. Always consult with legal and financial professionals to tailor these tips to your specific situation and to navigate the complexities of divorce negotiations effectively.

---