Why Is The Government Involved In My Marriage Anyway?

If you’re thinking about marriage or divorce, you might not realize how much the law is involved in these personal matters. A very old case from 1888, Maynard v. Hill, changed how the law views marriage and divorce in America. Even though it’s more than 100 years old, this case still affects family law today. Let’s break it down.
​
The Story Behind the Case
David Maynard married Lydia Maynard in 1852. Not long after, he left her and moved to the Oregon Territory to start a new life. While there, David asked the local legislature to end his marriage. They agreed, and he got a divorce. He then married someone else. Years later, Lydia’s children sued, saying the divorce wasn’t legal and that they deserved some of David’s property from his second marriage.

The question for the Supreme Court was simple: Could a legislature (like a local government) legally end someone’s marriage? And is marriage like any other contract that people make?

What the Supreme Court Decided
The Court said yes, the legislature could end the marriage, and here’s why it mattered. The justices explained that marriage isn’t just a private agreement between two people—it’s something the government has a say in. They said marriage is a public institution, meaning it’s important for society as a whole. Because of that, the government can make rules about it.

Why This Case Is Important
This case changed how marriage and divorce are seen under the law. Here’s why it’s still a big deal:

1. Marriage Is Different From Regular Contracts: The Court said marriage is not like signing a contract to buy a car or a house. It’s something that involves the public and the government, not just the people in the marriage.
2. The Government Can Make the Rules: The decision showed that the government has the power to regulate marriage and divorce. That’s why states can set rules for getting married, divorced, and even dividing property after a divorce.
3. A Foundation for Modern Family Law: This case paved the way for how we handle marriage-related issues today. It influenced later cases about marriage, divorce, and even who can get married.

What This Means for You
If you’re getting married or thinking about divorce, this case helps explain why the government is involved. When you get married, you’re entering a legal relationship that comes with rules and responsibilities. That’s why things like prenuptial agreements, child custody, and dividing property during a divorce are overseen by the courts.
Lessons for Divorce Cases TodayAs a divorce lawyer, I see how this case still matters. For example:

• The government’s role means that divorce is never just between the two people involved. The courts make sure everything is fair and follows the law.
• Issues like child custody or splitting assets can’t always be decided privately. The courts step in to protect everyone involved, especially kids.
• Knowing how the law views marriage and divorce can help you understand what to expect if you’re going through a divorce.

Why You Should Care About Maynard v. Hill
Maynard v. Hill isn’t just an old case—it’s the reason marriage and divorce work the way they do today. It explains why marriage isn’t just a private deal and why the courts and the government play a big role. If you’re dealing with a divorce, understanding this case can help you see the bigger picture and make informed decisions.
If you have questions about your situation, don’t hesitate to reach out. Divorce can be stressful, but understanding the law can make the process a little easier.